Authors: Laura Jobson; Casey Willoughby; Philippa Specker; Joshua Wong; Adriana Draganidis; Winnie Lau; Belinda Liddell · Research
How Does Cultural Background Affect Trauma Recovery and PTSD?
Research reveals important cultural differences in how Asian Americans and European Americans process and cope with trauma.
Source: Jobson, L., Willoughby, C., Specker, P., Wong, J., Draganidis, A., Lau, W., & Liddell, B. (2022). Investigating the associations between cognitive appraisals, emotion regulation and symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder among Asian American and European American trauma survivors. Scientific Reports, 12, 18127. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-22995-3
What you need to know
- Cultural background influences how people process trauma and cope with PTSD symptoms
- European Americans tend to focus more on individual experiences and expressing emotions
- Asian Americans often emphasize accepting circumstances and maintaining group harmony
- Understanding these differences can help improve trauma treatment for different cultural groups
Understanding Cultural Differences in Trauma Response
When Sarah experienced a serious car accident, she found herself constantly replaying the event in her mind and blamed herself for not being more careful. Meanwhile, Ming, who went through a similar experience, focused more on accepting what happened and finding ways to maintain harmony with her family despite her struggles. These different responses highlight an important reality about trauma: our cultural background shapes how we process and cope with difficult experiences.
How Culture Shapes Our Response to Trauma
Research shows that European Americans and Asian Americans often take different approaches to dealing with trauma. European Americans typically:
- Focus more on individual experiences
- Express emotions more openly
- Try to take direct control of situations
- Engage in more self-focused thinking
In contrast, Asian Americans tend to:
- Emphasize accepting circumstances
- Control emotional expression
- Focus on maintaining group harmony
- Take a more distanced perspective on experiences
Different Ways of Processing Emotions
The study found that European Americans were more likely to:
- Seek comfort from others
- Blame themselves for traumatic events
- Get caught in cycles of negative thinking
- Experience more distress when dwelling on negative thoughts
Asian Americans, however, showed greater tendency to:
- Accept difficult circumstances
- View adversity as having potential meaning
- Take a more detached perspective on negative thoughts
- Focus on adapting to situations rather than trying to change them
The Role of Cultural Values
These differences stem from deeper cultural values. European cultures often emphasize independence and personal control, while Asian cultures tend to value interdependence and harmony with others. These core values influence how people interpret traumatic events and choose coping strategies.
What This Means for You
If you’re dealing with trauma, consider how your cultural background might influence your healing journey:
- Recognize that there’s no single “right” way to process trauma
- Consider whether your coping strategies align with your cultural values
- Be open with therapists about your cultural background and values
- Understand that some therapeutic approaches may need to be adapted to fit your cultural perspective
Conclusions
- Cultural background significantly influences how people cope with trauma
- Different approaches to processing trauma can be equally valid and effective
- Mental health treatment should be tailored to match cultural values and beliefs
- Understanding cultural differences can lead to more effective trauma recovery support